BrewingTechniques
Turn-of-the-Century Beer and Brewing Practice
Definitions and Descriptions of British and American Beers,
circa 1908

"The beers brewed in the United Kingdom and its possessions show similar characteristic differences in their properties. . . . They are called ale, porter, and stout.

"Mild beers, whether ale, porter, or stout, are called such as undergo no secondary fermentation [sic], but are marketed about seven days after the principal fermentation is finished.

"Stock beers, or old beers, whether ale or stout, are such as have undergone a secondary fermentation and are stored about two months or more before marketing.

"The mild beers are distinguished from the stock beers by a more sweetish (mild) taste, containing more unfermented maltodextrin and less acid, the old beers, [sic] on the other hand, becoming more alcoholic and tart. . . .

"Stouts are quite dark, almost black, have a pronounced malt-caramel taste and aroma, a sweetish taste if mild, and a more or less tart taste, according to age and circumstances. They are brewed stronger than ales.

"Porter is brewed less strong than the old beers. It stands in a similar relation to stout as does a mild ale to a stock ale.

"The secondary fermentation of English stock beers -- as shown by Claussen in 1904 -- is entirely different from what is called secondary fermentation of, f.i., American or European beers . . . [it is] due, not to a genuine Saccharomyces, but to a certain torula, called Brettanomyces by its author . . . forming large quantities of acidic and ethereal substances, thus producing the typical flavor of the English stock beers.

"A pure cultivated yeast . . . cannot produce the flavor that is characteristic to stock or ale or stout, and is due exclusively to the action of Brettanomyces.

"[To make the secondary fermentation more reliable and predictable] Claussen recommends the addition of cultures of Brettanomyces to bring about the secondary fermentation."

[Return to Article


Guidelines for Brewing American Porter and Stout,
circa 1908

"The principal requirements, as compared with ale, are greater palatefulness, pronounced malt flavor, and darker color. It is best to use mixed malts, i.e., a mixture of high and low kiln-dried malts. If this cannot be had, caramel malt, 'black' malt, and sugar coloring ['porterine' or brewerıs caramel] to the required amount should be added.

"The mashing method and general treatment of porter and stout are the same as for stock ale [mash in at 65-66 degrees C (149-151 degrees F), then raise to 67.5 degrees C (154 degrees F) by underletting and stand one hour].

"Hops -- Porter, one and one quarter pounds per barrel; stout, two and one-half pounds per barrel. Added in the same manner as for stock ale [three equal additions in a two-hour boil]. Sugar (if used) to the amount of 25 percent, added in the kettle 30 mi nutes before running out. Porter, 13 percent Balling [13 degrees P, SG 1.053]; stout, from 16 to 18 percent Balling [16-18 degrees P, SG 1.065-1.073].

"Fermentation like stock ale. No dry hopping. Store three to four months." [Brettanomyces secondary fermentation was perhaps not standard practice in American ale breweries.]

  --From R. Wahl and M. Henius, American Handy Book of the Brewing, Malting, and Auxiliary Trades, vol. II (Wahl-Henius Institute, Chicago, 1908).

[Return to Article